August 26, 2022

Shikhar Dhawan or KL Rahul: The better fit for captaincy

By Yash Bhandigare

India’s team has undergone a surprise alteration thanks to BCCI ahead of the three-match ODI series against Zimbabwe. KL Rahul has taken over as the team’s captain instead of Shikhar Dhawan. However, concerns have been raised about this board decision. KL Rahul has yet to record a victory while serving as captain. Shikhar Dhawan has led to victories over Sri Lanka and the West Indies at the same time.

Rahul was awarded the captaincy in lieu of Dhawan for the Zimbabwe tour when he was healthy because the Indian Cricket Board has kept him as the deputy in all three formats to Rohit Sharma. Under Rahul’s leadership, the team was defeated in all four of India’s international cricket games, including three One Day International games and one Test.

Dhawan led the Indian team through six ODIs, with five of those matches ending in victories. Dhawan, has also led the team in three T20 international cricket matches, with a record of one victory and two defeats.

Better is Dhawan’s track record. In July last year, Dhawan led the Indian team for the first time. Additionally, he led the group on the most recent ODI trip to the West Indies. India won the three-ODI series against West Indies 3-0 while defeating the Caribbean nation 2-1. Last year's T20 series saw the Indian team lose 1-2 to Sri Lanka.

In Rohit Sharma’s absence during the Indian team’s January tour of South Africa, Rahul served as team captain for the first time. India was forced to lose all three One-Day Internationals it played against South Africa while he was in charge. In the second Test of this trip, Rahul took over as captain for the first time in Test cricket when Virat Kohli was unable to play due to injury, but India lost by seven wickets. This raises a lot of questions about KL Rahul. After February of this year, Rahul did not participate in another international match. He was supposed to participate in the series against West Indies but was unable to do so after testing positive for COVID-19.

However, Saba Karim, a former India selection committee member was not pleased with the BCCI and their choice of giving KL Rahul the captaincy duties over Shikhar Dhawan for the ongoing series against Zimbabwe. “KL Rahul should have participated in the series solely as a member; whether he served as captain or vice-captain is less significant. He returns after a lengthy absence. Senior player Shikhar Dhawan has performed well in white-ball cricket. Once you announce yourself as captain, you must accord him prominence”, were the thoughts of a frustrated figure in Karim.

KL Rahul had been given the all-clear by the BCCI medical staff to take part in the three-ODI tour of Zimbabwe. Rahul, assisted by Shikhar Dhawan, was selected as the captain for the brief visit.

Due to many health difficulties, he has missed the last six months of international cricket. And this was evident in his performances as he struggled to establish himself and leave his mark against weak opposition. Rahul did not perform with distinction and was only mediocre during the entire tour (batting-wise).

Even though Shikhar Dhawan, a senior colleague, was chosen ahead of him to captain the squad, the selection committee had hoped for a more commanding performance. Even though it was KL Rahul’s maiden series victory and they easily defeated their opponents, it did little to enhance the player’s reputation as a great leader in the eyes of the viewers.

Given that he is deputy and vice-captain to India’s RG Sharma, the player will undoubtedly have more possibilities to succeed in the years to come as the country searches for a leader with a stable mindset to take forward such heavy duties on their shoulder.

KL Rahul will look to cement that role over his teammate, Shikhar Dhawan, who has so far come out with flying colours when given the chance to lead the side. The struggle for spots in the Indian squad has always been well-known to the world, but now supporters, watchers, and enthusiastic sports fanatics will also be following the competition for who will lead the team with great interest.


Previous Post

Dutch League Match report- Sparta Rotterdam vs Ajax

Next Post

Real Salt Lake breaking new ground with their purchase of 18-year-old USYNT playmaker Diego Luna

Related Articles

  • July 13, 2022

    Kiran Prabhu Navgire- The Nagaland run machine

  • July 19, 2022

    India vs Leicestershire – a well-utilized warm-up game for India but far from match ready.

  • July 21, 2022

    India's rising youth star- Umran Malik

  • August 04, 2022

    How will Bangladesh fare in this year’s Asia Cup?

  • August 05, 2022

    India’s rising U-19 Captain – Yash Dhull

  • August 08, 2022

    Smriti Mandhana – The backfoot ballerina of Indian cricket

  • August 10, 2022

    Ashleigh Gardner- the buttress of the Australian cricket team

  • August 10, 2022

    Indian women's team clinches silver at CWG 2022 with their best performances

  • August 11, 2022

    Spinners Rip Through The Windies As India Ends The Series With A 4-1 Win

  • August 12, 2022

    Should Pakistan change squad ahead of Asia Cup?

  • August 12, 2022

    Is the Indian team better off without KL Rahul?

  • August 17, 2022

    India’s all-rounders' crucial role in winning the Asia Cup

  • August 18, 2022

    Top 3 fast bowlers for India ahead of Asia Cup 2022

  • August 19, 2022

    Shoaib Akhtar – A life and career spent on the highway to the danger zone

  • August 22, 2022

    The Indian women's cricket team deserve attention and acclaim after the Commonwealth Games

  • August 23, 2022

    Top 3 most crucial players for Pakistan in Asia Cup 2022

  • August 24, 2022

    Jhulan Goswami retires from International Cricket

  • August 26, 2022

    Shubman Gill owns the show as India record whitewash against Zimbabwe

  • August 26, 2022

    Sanju Samson – India’s most elegant batsmen with a burden of perception

  • August 26, 2022

    How can Sri Lanka prepare ahead for the Asia Cup 2022

  • August 26, 2022

    Shikhar Dhawan or KL Rahul: The better fit for captaincy

  • August 27, 2022

    Harmanpreet Kaur: Leading the new generation of Indian Women’s cricket

  • August 27, 2022

    How will Shaheen Afridi's ruling out from the Asia Cup impact Pakistan

  • August 29, 2022

    Afghanistan starts strong in the first match of DP Asia Cup 2022

  • August 30, 2022

    DP Asia Cup 2022 India vs Pakistan: Pandya finishes off in style for a thrilling win

  • August 30, 2022

    Dutch League Match Report- Excelsior vs PSV

  • August 30, 2022

    Cathryn Lorraine Fitzpatrick: A Fast Bowler Who Still Has No Equal

  • September 01, 2022

    India under Virat Kohli in Test Cricket

  • September 01, 2022

    DP Asia Cup 2022 Bangladesh vs Afghanistan: Afghanistan hold off Bangladesh in tense Asia Cup encounter

  • September 02, 2022

    DP Asia Cup 2022 Review- India vs Hong Kong

  • September 02, 2022

    DP Asia Cup 2022 Review- Sri Lanka vs Bangladesh: Sri Lanka sends Bangladesh out of Asia Cup in thriller

  • September 05, 2022

    James Anderson: First Cricketer in Test History to reach incredible feat; leaves behind Tendulkar, Ponting

  • September 05, 2022

    DP Asia Cup 2022 Review- Sri Lanka vs Afghanistan: Sri Lanka beat Afghanistan by 4 wickets

  • September 07, 2022

    DP Asia Cup 2022 Review- India vs Pakistan

  • September 08, 2022

    Shubman Gill: The youngster with the hallmarks of a future India batting mainstay

  • September 08, 2022

    DP Asia Cup 2022 Review- India vs Sri Lanka: SL beat India by 6 wickets, makes way to the final match

  • September 09, 2022

    DP Asia Cup 2022 Review- Pakistan vs Afghanistan: Pak joins SL for the final match of the Asia Cup

  • September 12, 2022

    DP World Asia Cup 2022- Review – India vs Afghanistan

  • September 13, 2022

    Sri Lanka wins DP Asia Cup 2022 after beating Pakistan by 23 runs

  • September 16, 2022

    DP Asia Cup 2022: How Sri Lanka defied the odds of becoming the champions and clinched the title

  • September 19, 2022

    Bumrah, Pant, and Ashwin secure a place in the T20 World Cup squad

  • September 19, 2022

    Top 3 Performances in DP Asia Cup 2022

  • September 20, 2022

    Australia Captain announces ODI retirement, will not play next year’s World Cup


Post a comment